The Second Greatest Story Ever
Told
**1/2
out of ****

Now
here is an interesting, completely original idea for a movie:
An offbeat comedy about the adventures of Jesus Christ’s
little brother, set in 1960s Brooklyn. If this sounds irreverent,
that’s probably because it is, though I’d like to
think that if Jesus really is the Son of God, then he’s
got a good sense of humor and knows the difference between poking
fun at the earthly clichés built up around him and making
fun of his message and divinity.
Unfortunately,
while this short little film gives us the impression that its
humor will lean more towards the former, and while it is cute
while it lasts, The Second Greatest Story Ever Told is
over before it ever has a chance to begin. The subtitle in front
of the film reads Chapter One, and it isn’t kidding.
Granted, this first chapter is certainly well done, but where’s
the rest of the movie? It is difficult to judge a film simply
from its opening scenes, but this is all we are given, and to
my knowledge, no additional chapters were ever made. There could
be a number of reasons why it was never finished: Perhaps it lost
funding. Perhaps it was considered too blasphemous by fundamentalist
groups to go on, and the filmmakers caved in against pressure.
I don’t know, but it’s a pity that these brief moments
are all that became of this original, well-written premise, because
judging from the opening scenes, this could have been a very charming
comedy.
Mary
Weinstein (Mira Sorvino) is a sheltered, twenty-four year old
Jewish virgin still living with her parents, who are anxious to
get her married. As it turns out, God has other plans: While on
a port-o-potty at a third-rate amusement park, Mary becomes divinely
pregnant, only this time, there is no Gabriel to let her in on
the news. Feeling ill, Mary visits the hospital. There is a charming
scene between her and her doctor in which he tells Mary that she
only has “seven months,” and she is terrified, because
she has misunderstood and believes that he is talking about some
sort of terminal disease. After the doctor clarifies that she
is going to have a baby, things only get more terrifying for the
poor girl.
Before
Mary can become too overcome with worry, Gabriel (Malcolm McDowell)
eventually shows up in a ray of blue light and heavenly-harp music,
a musical style that he announces he is bored with and switches
to classic rock. He apologizes profusely for being late, blaming
modern medicine for being more advanced than the last time he
had to do all of this. He then runs through the spiel as if he
has done it before, with one minor difference: “Fear not,
for you have found favor with God. And behold, you will conceive
in your womb and bear a son, and you shall call his name...Jake.”
Mary naturally wants to know why God has chosen her, and Gabriel
only shrugs and says, “Your purity. Your innocence. Your
goodness. I also think He likes your eyes.”
After
this supernatural encounter, Mary meets the bumbling Joey (short
for Joseph, get it? Eh? Eh?), an old boyfriend now running
a potato chip business, and they have a very delightful scene
together where he proposes to her, immaculate conception be darned.
There is another humorous moment when Jewish Mary walks into a
Catholic church, thinks the holy water is a water fountain, and
tries to model her posture after a statue of the Virgin Mary.
So,
Mary and Joey get married. Then the baby is born—and that’s
it. There is no more. The credits start rolling, as Baby Jake
sits in his crib. Just as I was relaxing and getting into the
film, allowing its cute performances and clever writing hook me
in, it was over, and my grin was knocked right off of my face.
That’s it? I asked, over and over again. That’s
it?
I
had to go to the Internet
Movie Database to get the rest of the story. Evidently, the
entire film was supposed to be a social commentary that discussed
the “evolving universal religious paradigm in a world whose
many disparate peoples are drawing continually closer to one another.
… Mira Sorvino plays the mother of a modern messiah, Christ's
‘younger, dumber brother’ who must continue ‘the
family business.’” Whoever wrote this plot summary
must have read the finished script and gotten a better look into
some of these themes and dialogue, but that’s more than
we get.
This
leaves me with a dilemma as a first critic. How do I review the
first chapter of a good book? That’s what I’m stuck
doing with this article, and I can only conclude that though this
film is certainly charming, because it never goes so far as to
even finish its first act, I cannot recommend it. For what it’s
worth, I also couldn’t recommend a copy of Great Expectations
that had all but the first few pages missing.
Click
here to to learn about the many cinematic faces of Christ.
Cast:
Mira Sorvino: Mary Weinstein
Malcolm McDowell: Gabriel
Rya Kihlstedt: Arleen
Josh Pais: Joey Joesephson
A Tapestry Film Production.
Directed by Ralph Howard and Katharina Otto. Written by Ralph
Howard. No M.P.A.A. rating (a few obscenities, otherwise okay
for kids). Running time: Approximately 29 minutes. Year of release:
1994.