Carnival of Souls
***
out of ****

Carnival
of Souls is the best Twilight Zone-feature film
ever made, and while this wasn’t its intention, I mean it
in the best way possible. All that’s lacking are the Rod
Serling bookends and the trademark theme song. Like The Twilight
Zone, it is predictable, with a one-note storyline that never
steers from its inevitable, “shocking” ending that
is so obvious that it isn’t shocking at all. But also like
The Twilight Zone, it tells its story well and works
within its own limitations to conjure up some genuine moments
of horror. I remained compelled throughout the film and often
shuddered at its startling images, and this is more than I can
say about most horror films these days.
The
story concerns a young woman named Mary (a doe-eyed Candace Hilligoss)
who is in a near-tragic accident in which she and her friends
lose control of their car and swerve off of a bridge. As officials
fruitlessly attempt to fish the car out of the water, Mary emerges,
stunned but seemingly unharmed. Haunted by her near-death experience
and the loss of her friends, Mary grows withdrawn and reclusive.
In desperate need of a change of pace, she accepts the position
of church organist in some faraway city, though she doesn’t
necessarily believe in God or the supernatural. Events begin to
unfold that give us a feeling that by the end of the film, she
will.
You
shouldn't have any difficultly discovering the twists along the
way, but just in case, I won’t reveal too much beyond this.
I will say that as Mary begins her new life, she grows paranoid
and starts having visions of a pasty-faced man (director Herk
Harvey) reaching out to her sinisterly, and he gets progressively
closer to her with each dream. These visions seem linked to an
abandoned carnival on the outskirts of her new town, and though
Mary is terrified of what is happening to her, she is determined
to solve the mystery of the carnival and these eerie dreams.
Carnival
of Souls is certainly an impressive work, if for no other
reason than its ability to maintain ingenuity despite its shoestring
budget and technical limitations. It was made by a company that
never made another feature film, before or since, but it is nevertheless
extremely effective, and not unlike the original Night
of the Living Dead and Halloween in its ability
to use its amateurish qualities to creates its own, original appeal.
The obviously white paste smeared on the faces of the ghosts/zombies
that beckon to Mary in her dreams are certainly distracting, and
most of the acting and dialogue are pretty stilted, but these
flaws add to its nostalgic charm and overall eeriness.
The
final moments, in which Mary confronts her fears at the carnival
and discovers the “truth,” are particularly terrifying
in the way that they resonate with gripping, surrealistic horror.
In the end, not all of the puzzle pieces have been put together
satisfactorily, but I didn’t mind so much. Mary’s
fate is so obvious that it would have been distracting if the
story hadn’t followed through with its clear intentions,
and the question marks left hovering over her journey maintain
a respectable level of mystery in what is an otherwise predictable
conclusion.
I
think what I like best about Carnival of Souls is the
way that it plays on our natural, everyday fears of isolation
and the unknown. When I lived in the lower forty-eight, I used
to drive alone in unbending streets in the darkness of the night,
and it was easy to give into the sensation that I was not alone
out there. You have also found, I am sure, that in the quiet solitude
of night driving, it is easy to for your imagination to get away
with you: Is that a reflection in the passenger-side mirror—some
demon or lonely ghost staring at you from the outside? Or when
you are alone in the room of an old, dark house of some distant
relative: As you smell the ancient dust in the guest bedroom,
you think you see a face staring at you through the old, faded
curtains. Our wits, of course, eventually get the better of our
fears, and we tell ourselves that there is no one in the passenger
side window or through the curtains. What is truly terrifying
about Carnival of Souls, of course, is that there really
is a white, evil face staring back at us. It smiles at us devilishly,
with a look that notifies us that it wants no less than our souls.
Cue
The Twilight Zone theme.
Cast:
Candace Hilligoss: Mary Henry
Herk Harvey: "The Man"
Sidney Berger: John Linden
Frances Feist: Mrs. Thomas
Art Ellison: Minister
Stan Levitt: Dr. Samuels
A film by Harcourt Productions. Directed by Herk Harvey. Written
by John Clifford. No M.P.A.A. rating, but probably a PG-13. No
violence, sex, or profanity, but plenty of scares that would certainly
frighten young viewers. Running time: 78 minutes. Original United
States theatrical release date: September 26, 1962.