The King of Comedy
****
out of ****
Martin Scorsese excels at making two kinds of films, and he does
each with such ferocious originality and skillful technique that
I am convinced that he is the greatest living director, from the
United States or anywhere. The first type is the biography, in
which he chronicles his subject matter, usually extremely flawed
human beings, with such painstaking detail that the effect is
breathtaking and never forced. Such films include Goodfellas,
Raging
Bull, Kundun,
and Casino. Scorsese’s second type of film is what
I call a “punch line movie,” in which the director
draws very specific characters through very specific situations
and events, and it all comes together only in the last few minutes
of the film, sometimes in the final frame. The viewer is taken
on a long, engaging ride, and then, POW! The point of it all—often
ironic, often surprising, and always profound—hits us like
a sock in the eye. This type includes Taxi Driver, The
Last Temptation of Christ, Gangs of New York,
and The King of Comedy. In both types of his films, we
see our faces on the people we are watching, and our external
viewing is turned inward (in fact, I would say that his only missteps—The
Color of Money and Cape Fear—were films which
he steered away from his usual filmmaking techniques; I do not
count, of course, Boxcar Bertha). Scorsese is a true
patron of cinema, and certainly one of the greatest artists of
all time.
Because
his films are so loaded with surprises that must be discovered
by the viewer, I am hesitant to reveal anything about the plot
of The King of Comedy. Like most of Scorsese’s
best films, it takes place in New York City, and it stars Robert
De Niro in a role that is completely convincing and defined, to
the point that we forget that we are watching an actor and are
completely convinced that this is a man driven by his strange
obsessions. In this case, De Niro is Rupert Pupkin, and he is
obsessed with Jerry Langford (Jerry Lewis, more or less playing
himself), a stand-up comedian who hosts a late night network comedy
show. Pupkin certainly has a severe case of celebrity worship,
but he is more complicated than that—he dreams of becoming
the next “king of comedy” by performing his own stand-up
act, and he will achieve his goal by any means necessary. Any
means.
As
we watch this strange man, we are reluctantly forced to realize
that perhaps Pupkin isn’t so different from us. After all,
celebrity worship seems to have less to do with obsessing over
a famous performer because of his talent more than it has to do
with the fact that we want to be as famous and as talented as
they are. Certainly Scorsese, De Niro, and Lewis, who are the
best at what they do, understand the public’s often bizarre
relationship with Hollywood personalities, and their work in this
film shows its effect on both the obsessing and the obsessed.
In particular, Scorsese and De Niro pull no stops in presenting
Pupkin and his world as depressing, pathetic, but not altogether
unlike us. Pupkin is an exaggeration of anyone who has ever put
a poster of their favorite actor on their wall and thought, “I
love this guy,” when they’re really thinking, “I
wish I was this guy.” His room, located in his mother’s
apartment, is decorated with Jerry Langford memorabilia. He often
practices his own stand-up comedy show, all the while daydreaming
about that not-so-far-away day when he and Langford will sit together
in restaurants as peers, shooting the crap as people come and
ask for their autographs. His fantasies are often interrupted
by his mother, always heard and never seen, who calls him down
to dinner or asks him to keep the noise down. When she speaks
and Pupkin fumes back at her, we realize how deranged he is, but
we also realize that we can relate to his daydreams because of
our own taste for fantasizing about being celebrities, or being
famous, or having people ask for our autographs while we sit in
restaurants, shooting the crap.
Because
of its intense, dark subject matter, The King of Comedy
probably sounds like a thriller, or even a sort of horror story.
In a way, it is both. The characters are depressing, and the circumstances
that they find themselves in are often painful to watch. In the
third act, when Pupkin and his equally loony girlfriend (a delightful
Sandra Bernhard) implement their plan to use Jerry Langford to
propel themselves into stardom, all three characters find themselves
in a circumstances worthy of a Hitchcock film, and directed with
just as much finesse. Yet Scorsese chooses to make this film a
comedy, and to create a humorous plot for the deranged Pupkin
to exist. Even his scenes of complete, obsessive delusion are
played for laughs, and the ultimate consequences of his actions
bring more smiles than grimaces. Any moment that makes us wiggle
in discomfort (Pupkin roaming around in the network television’s
studio office) are almost immediately followed by moments of pure
comedy (Pupkin being escorted out by security). I think Scorsese
choose this approach because the subject matter is too intense:
Pupkin is such an honest, if extreme, reflection of average America
that only by playing the character for laughs could we be able
to stand the movie and appreciate its message at all. In a way,
The King of Comedy is the complete opposite of a previous
Scorsese/De Niro collaboration, Taxi Driver. Both are
about obsessive misfits who often find themselves in uncomfortable
situations, and both men are played by De Niro. In Taxi Driver,
Scorsese contrasts the film’s intensity by showcasing characters
more demented than the protagonist, relieving us of thinking that
De Niro’s character is the maddest of them all. In The
King of Comedy, Scorsese boldly asserts that Pupkin is the
most insane man in the city, and he plays Pupkin for laughs, relieving
the audience of feeling too uncomfortable by the man.
All
of this leads to some brilliant closing moments, in which Scorsese
lifts the curtain and reveals The King of Comedy as one
of his “punch line movies.” We realize that Scorsese
is commenting not only on celebrity worship, but also the entertainment
business and media influence, and he has made his statements by
simply analyzing the life, personality, and fantasies of one crazy
man. When we see where Pupkin’s obsessions have surprisingly
taken him, we are equally surprised that we’re not all that
surprised. POW!

Cast:
Rupert Pupkin: Robert De Niro
Jerry Langford: Jerry Lewis
Sandra Bernhard: Masha
Diahnne Abbott: Rita Keane
Shelley Hack: Cathy Long
Twentieth Century Fox presents
an Embassy International release. Directed by Martin Scorsese.
Written by Paul D. Zimmerman. Rated PG, for brief language, sexuality,
and adult situations. Running time: 101 minutes. Original United
States release date: February 18, 1983.