Quigley Down Under
***
out of ****

Quigley
Down Under is a title that reads like a sequel, and this
is perfectly acceptable. We see the tired, sullen American sharpshooter
stepping off of a boat into the rough, tough world of turn-of-the-century
Australian Outback, and we feel like we have known him all of
our lives and experienced countless other adventures with him
before this one. That’s because Matthew Quigley, as played
by Tom Selleck, is the sum-total of every classic cowboy that
has come before him. He has the cool spirit of Clint Eastwood,
the square jaw of Johnny Cash, and the heroic chivalry (and right
hook) of John Wayne. He is a delightful reminder of the classic
B-cowboys of yesteryear. The film that he inhabits, also assembled
together out of bits and pieces of the westerns that inspired
it, is a likewise delightful reminder of the old-fashioned charm
of the Wild West according to John Ford and Sergio Leone.
Westerns
will always have a special place in my heart, on the sole basis
that they contain heroes that owe more to the Knights of the Round
Table than to Rambo and James Bond. Today’s heroes seem
to take pride in their rebellious natures: They are macho, male
chauvinist, and seem to rank their success by the amount of women
that they lay and the buildings that they blow up. Cowboys, on
the other hand, maintain a proper, more dignified form of chivalry.
They tip their hats to the ladies, fight to defend their honor,
and will only fight if they’ve been wronged. If the Wild
West was a man’s world, cowboys show that a man can be a
gentleman and still get some action.
Matthew
Quigley’s adventure might not take place in the Wild West,
but as far as he’s concerned, there doesn’t seem to
be much difference. In the film's opening scenes, Quigley arrives
in the Outback to answer an ad for a sharpshooter from a rich
plantation owner. Right off the boat, things must seem like home:
He defends the honor of a lady named Crazy Cora (played by Laura
San Giacomo, in a role, as her name suggests, a bit more complicated
than the usual damsel in distress), insults a bad guy with a cheap
shot, gets into a fist fight with several well-armed gentlemen,
and wins. Psychologists might call Quigley’s actions the
result of the pent-up agitation of an old fashioned cowboy to
see some action after three months on a boat. Others might call
it preposterous and clichéd. I call it a great entrance.
Quigley,
accompanied by Crazy Cora, is quickly taken to his new employer,
a seedy, weasel-like plantation owner named Elliott Martson. As
played by Alan Rickman, he is intelligent, conniving, and he has
a temper as fast as his draw. We know immediately that Martson
will be the villain of the piece, because A) he dresses in black,
and B) he is played by Alan Rickman. Quigley is a bit cautious
of his new employer because he seems to understand the rules of
the West that the bad guys always wear black. Martson seems a
little slower, offers Quigley the job of killing Aborigine locals
who infest the surrounding plains and deserts of his plantation,
and is quickly thrown out of his window by the good-natured Quigley,
who is, of course, immediately fired, beaten up by Martson’s
men, and dumped in the desert to die—along with Crazy Cora,
of course.
I
could give away more, and elaborate how Quigley and Crazy Cora
will fall in love, get help from Aborigines who substitute for
Native Americans, and eventually plan a Climactic Showdown with
Martson. Of if you know anything about the western genre, you
know that all of this is inevitable, and it’s what you came
to see. In a way, B-level westerns are like James Bond films (and
Bon Jovi albums, but that’s another film
review). They stick to a strict formula, never straying from
their course: The hero is introduced. The hero takes a stand,
proving his honor. The hero gets chased. The hero has a ferocious
shootout. The hero kills the bad guy. The hero gets the girl.
Of course, the plotline is ridiculous, filled with lame one-liners,
impossible shootouts, and a routine ending, but you must understand
the nature of the B-western: This is in the tradition of Saturday
matinees like Stagecoach and Rio Bravo, not
award-winning characters studies like Unforgiven and
Lonesome Dove (even though Simon Wincer directs both
the latter and this). Quigley Down Under sticks to the
formula and tells it story well.
Certainly,
a more complex movie would have provided us with a hero that was
a little less static. A story about an American who gets stuck
among the indigenous natives of the Outback could have been an
effective statement about racism and coming-of-age. A bolder film
would call for a racist protagonist to spend time with the Aborigines
and learn to appreciate them, a la Dances with Wolves
or Witness. But then again, as we watch Quigley shoot
his enemies down with his 1874 Sharps Buffalo Rifle at twelve-thousand
yards, we’re too busy grinning to think that deeply.
With
the strict formula come elements of great appeal. Selleck emits
charm and dignity in the role of the modern knight. He is an acceptable
modern-day replacement for John Wayne and Roy Rogers, channeling
them but also creating his own sincerely noble hero. There is
a moment when he teaches local Aborigines the secret of the lasso,
and it strikes a perfect note—he is a completely likable
guy, and that’s a rare thing in today’s action heroes.
As would be expected with a western, we also get fine cinematography
showcasing the Outback, superior action sequences, a rousing score,
and some clever lines—particularly in the interaction between
Quigley and Crazy Cora, who is a well-written heroine. Spotting
these western motifs is like going down the checklist of necessary
clichés, but Quigley Down Under demonstrates that
they are motifs because they work.

Cast:
Tom Selleck: Matthew Quigley
Laura San Giacomo: Crazy Cora
Alan Rickman: Elliott Marston
Chris Haywood: Major Ashley-Pitt
An MGM release of a Pathé
Entertainment production. Directed by Simon Wincer. Written by
John Hill. Rated PG-13, for action-packed violence, brief language,
and occasional innuendo. Running time: 119 minutes. Original United
States theatrical release date: October 19, 1990.