The Messiah
***1/2
out of ****

Before
viewing this film, I had certainly beheld many different cinematic
faces of Christ, all of which varied in nature and personality.
I had seen traditional
a Christ, a laughing
Christ, a somber
Christ, Christ updated
into modern day, Christ updated into a futuristic
age, a counterfeit
Christ, Christ as a clown,
Christ as a revolutionary,
Christ as a sacrificial lamb, and Christ attempting to successfully juggle
his humanity with his divinity. But as I watched Roberto Rossellini’s
The Messiah, a serious insight occurred to me: I had
never seen Christ as a carpenter, even though the Bible teaches
that this was his trade. This film made me keenly aware of his
profession for the first time: Here is Christ who is happy to
sit at the beach on a hot, dry day and work diligently on a boat
while teaching his disciples his familiar parables. After watching
so many complex takes on the Son of God, this uncomplicated but
completely original variation was so simple and so profound that
I smiled ear to ear, and my day’s entire perspective leapt
up a few degrees brighter.
Roberto
Rossellini is, of course, the creator of neorealism, an Italian-based
genre which specializes in creating films as close to real life
as possible, without any cinematic tricks or gimmicks. The
Messiah was his last film, made in 1975 (he died in 1977),
and it is also one of his best. It carries on the neorealist tradition
that he made famous with films like Open
City. Like that film, this is a sincere, heartfelt approach
to very serious subject matter. There is no standout performance,
no tricky camera angles, no swelling music. The power is in the
reality of the characters and situations, and we observe them
as extras in the background, not as a movie-goers.
Rossellini’s
approach to Christ is unique and completely refreshing. The
Messiah begins hundreds of years before his birth, as the
Israelites move into the Promised Land and desire a king to rule
over them. These scenes depict a corrupt, selfish nation that
is more interested in being like other nations than actually serving
God and doing good, and Rossellini uses these moments to set up
his own arguments about Christ. Like Pier Paolo Pasolini, Rossellini
was an atheist, not so much interested in making a devoutly Christian
film as he was presenting Christ as the ultimate example of the
perfect man—the man who recognizes the need to do total
goodness in a world of corruption. At one point, the Virgin Mary
tells a child, “The kingdom of heaven is here, but people
have forgotten, because they have forgotten how to do good.”
For Rossellini, this understanding is the light that Christ is
bringing to the world, and his own self-concept that he is the
perfect man, living by example for others to see, is what makes
him the Messiah.
After
the prologue and a few brief traditional scenes concerning Christ’s
infancy and childhood, Christ the man is introduced as he watches
John the Baptist crying in the desert for all to repent. His baptism
by John is a neorealistic masterpiece, handled in one, full-shot
take. There are no dramatic pauses, no glowing light from heaven,
no Godly voice speaking above the clouds; Christ gets in line
to be baptized, he and John exchange a few words, Jesus is baptized,
he leaves, and John baptizes the next in line. All emotion and
relevance are in their words and their facial expressions, and
Rossellini keeps it that simple.
The
simplicity of the baptism is the example that the rest of the
film will follow. Rossellini downplays the divinity and miracles
of Christ and emphasizes his teachings. Only two miracles are
seen, and they are so underplayed that they barely come across
as miracles at all. Jesus is presented as not interested in gathering
a large following or making intensely spiritual or political statements
that challenge the system. He rather seeks to be a personal, one-on-one
teacher—a quiet, working class man who wants to work on
his carpentry trade as he preaches his parables about love and
forgiveness. In nearly every scene in which Jesus teaches, he
is presented as blunt, introspective, and very human, almost always
working with his hands as he teaches his small group of disciples.
Christ
is very humble here, not wanting to place too much attention on
himself. In fact, he seems happier with his few disciples, teaching
them quietly in the streets and in his workplace. Rather, it is
the Pharisees and Christ's own followers who seem obsessed with
giving his person and ministry a large, vocal profile. As Jesus
quietly teaches, the Pharisees begin screaming at him, questioning
his teachings. It is they who draw a crowd and make people notice,
not Christ himself. When John the Baptist sends his messengers
to inquire whether or not Christ is the Messiah, it is a disciple,
not Christ, who cries out loudly, “Tell John that the blind
see and the lame walk!” Jesus quietly rebukes the disciple,
and tells John’s follower, “Tell him that the poor
have good news preached to them.” Rossellini also gives
the disciples many of Christ’s more politically-charged
teachings, perhaps indicating that they gave him credit for their
own zealous philosophies when they wrote the gospels.
Not
that Rossellini is by any means side-stepping traditional views of Christ’s divinity.
Jesus still addresses God as “Father,” and he still
proclaims that he is the only way to reach God. He is still crucified
and resurrected, though those scenes are vastly underplayed. The
key difference here is that Rossellini argues that Christ’s
message was one of finding truth and peace in the common, everyday
things of life. He came to live by quiet example, to set people
free from their sin by teaching them how to appreciate what they
have, and how to live a good, righteous life by treating others
with kindness and fairness. The world, Rossellini argues, needs
a perfect man to demonstrate how to be led away from selfishness
and corruption just as much as they need a great teacher and a
redeemer. His Christ manages to be all three.
As
long as Rossellini stays on this path, his film is flawless. There
are a few moments that tend to drag, namely Christ's childhood
and trial, which focus on the more traditional aspects of Christ’s
life without applying them to the central thesis. These scenes
offer nothing new, and they aren’t anything that we have
seen before, or better. That said, most of The Messiah
is a masterful work. It is refreshing after viewing so many complicated
approaches to the nature of Christ and his teachings to see a
film that handles his ministry with such simplicity. Could Christ
have been laid-back, just one of the guys, AND God made flesh?
By reimaging the nature of his message, Rossellini argues that
he could.
Click
here to to learn about the many cinematic faces of Christ.
Cast:
Pier Maria Rossi: Jesus Christ
Carlos Carvalho De Carvalho
Jean Martin
Fausto Di Bella
Directed by Roberto Rossellini.
Written by Rossellini and Silvia D'Amico Bendico. No M.P.A.A.
rating, but fine for kids. Running time: 145 minutes. Original
year of release: 1976. Italian with English subtitles.